clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

2012 NFL Draft Grades: Browns First Round Picks Receive Mixed Reviews

It's clear that Tom Heckert and Pat Shurmur drafted the two guys they wanted when Thursday's first round started, addressing the offensive skill positions and adding Trent Richardson and Brandon Weeden. But some vehemently disagree with Heckert's assessment, particularly with what they gave up in the trade with the Vikings to move up to No. 3 as well as the selection of Weeden in the first round.

MORE: SB Nation's First Round Draft Grades For The Browns

Pete Prisco of is just one draft analyst that didn't exactly give the Browns passing grades for their two first round selections. Prisco thought the Browns gave away way too much, for a running back, who's elite, but not worth the value given his position. Prisco gave the pick a "C", writing:

Why, Browns? Yes, he's a good player, but backs don't decide Super Bowls anymore. And you gave up picks?

But he was even more harsh on the Weeden selection, handing out a big fat "F" for the No. 22 pick. Prisco thinks he's hardly an upgrade over current starter Colt McCoy, who the Browns may send packing in the near future. On Weeden, he writes:

I don't like this pick at all. Is he really that much better than McCoy? Plus, he's 28. Weird. Are the Browns better?

Check out SB Nation's complete recap of the AFC North's first round picks:

For more news, analysis, and discuss of the Browns 2012 Draft, visit Dawgs By Nature. For all your NFL Draft news and notes, visit SB Nation's NFL hub as well as Mocking The Draft.

Check out     the SB Nation Channel on YouTube

Photographs by spatulated, Triple Tri, and chrischappelear used in background montage under Creative Commons. Thank you.